7 Best Blenders for Protein Shakes: Immersion and Countertop
If you intend to build muscle mass, protein shakes are a must have in your diet. Traditionally, you would need to have a shaker bottle to mix your proteins and this was a very inconveniencing and sometimes tiring method to use when making the drink.
The good thing though is that there are blenders that are designed to handle making protein shakes with ease, and these drastically reduce the preparation time so that you can have your drink quickly made before hitting the gym.
To help you pick a good product for this task, this article looks at some of the best blenders for protein shakes by detailing their features for easy comparison between them.
- 7 Best Blenders For Protein Shakes – Reviews
- 1. SharkNinja BL610 – Best Overall Blender for Protein Shakes
- 2. NutriBullet NBR-1201 – Good Blender for Protein Shakes
- 3. Oster BLSTPB – Best Protein Shake Blender for the Money
- 4. Vitamix 5200 – Most Powerful Protein Shake Blender
- 5. Cuisinart CPB-300 – Best Blender Set for Protein Shakes
- 6. Hamilton Beach 51101BA – Best Personal Blender for Protein Shakes
- 7. Hamilton Beach 58148A – Best Blender for Smoothies
- How to Buy the Best Blenders for Protein Shakes
7 Best Blenders For Protein Shakes – Reviews
1. SharkNinja BL610 Professional Countertop Blender
Fast protein shake blender that features a powerful 1000-watt motor and a 6-blade assembly to crush ingredients in seconds
2. NutriBullet NBR-1201 High-Speed Blender
Small sized blender with a single high-speed setting and comes with 3 to-go blending cups
3. Oster BLSTPB My Blend 250-Watt Blender
Very affordable protein shake blender with a 250-watt motor and a resettable fuse for protecting the motor from overheating
4. Vitamix 5200 Professional Grade Blender
Very expensive and powerful professional blender with a cool running 1490-watt motor, a metal drive system and hardened stainless-steel blades
5. Cuisinart CPB-300 Blender with LED Indicator Light
Compact blender with an easy-to-use electronic touchpad and LED indicators to show its power and settings status.
6. Hamilton Beach 51101BA Personal Blender
Personal protein-shake blender with a less powerful but energy efficient 175-watt motor and a single pulse speed setting that makes it very easy to use
7. Hamilton Beach Blender with Glass Jar
Preset-based blender with 12 different blending functions and a glass jar that is designed to create a wave action to pull the ingredients down towards the blades for smooth and even blending
1. SharkNinja BL610 – Best Overall Blender for Protein Shakes
- Power: 1000 Watts
- Speed: 3 speeds
- Cup size: 72 ounces
- Material: Plastic
Even though you do not require a huge amount of power to blend your protein shake, SharkNinja’s BL610 ensures that you get quite a lot of it so that you can prepare the drink quickly and to a very smooth texture.
The product features a powerful 1000-watt motor, which is very good for blending protein shakes and also capable of crushing ice for other types of drinks such as smoothies.
This motor’s power is controllable using a 3-speed setting, which lets you whip protein shakes and soft fruits in low speed, blend semi-hard fruits in medium speed and crush hard frozen fruits and ice in high speed.
Additionally, the unit also features a pulse speed for more manual control over the blending process so that you can make your drink have just the right texture that you want.
On the upper side, blending is done inside a large BPA free and dishwasher safe 72-ounce container, which is capable of making a protein shake serving for your large family, just in case all of you want to build muscle mass.
For the actual crushing, the jug features a 6-blade assembly in which the blades are arranged in sets of 2 along a vertical shaft from the bottom to the top of the pitcher. This construction ensures that the ingredients inside are crushed in seconds for faster blending.
2. NutriBullet NBR-1201 – Good Blender for Protein Shakes
- Power: 600 Watts
- Speed: 1 speed
- Cup size: 8, 16, 24 ounces
- Material: Plastic
NutriBullet’s high-speed blender also features a relatively powerful 600-watt motor that is capable of blending protein shakes quickly and also has enough torque to crush through ice and hard fruits for blending smoothies, purees and other similar types of frozen drinks.
Despite its high-speed performance, this unit has a very small footprint, which makes it fit very easily on tight countertop spaces. In terms of height, it is only 13.5 inches tall with the cup attached and this means that it can fit easily under kitchen cabinets even with the cup on.
For blending, the NBR-1201 features a single high-speed setting that lets you pulverize veggies, fruits and of course, protein ingredients with ease, using a set of 4 patented stainless-steel blades.
The rotation from these blades causes a cyclonic action that circulates the food around the cup for fast and even blending across the board.
Crushing is done inside either of the 3 cups that it comes with, which are quite small but are very easy to handle. The largest of them is a 24-ounce cup followed by 16-ounce and lastly, an 8-ounce cup. 2 resealable lids are included in the pack, making the cups to-go ready.
3. Oster BLSTPB – Best Protein Shake Blender for the Money
- Power: 250 Watts
- Speed: 1 speed
- Cup size: 20 ounces
- Material: Plastic
Oster’s BLSTPB is a very affordable blender but this does not mean that it is a low-quality product. Its low price is actually as a result of various factors such as its less powerful 250-watt motor.
This motor is powerful enough to make protein shakes as well as blend soft fruits, but it might not be the best for crushing hard fruits and ice. On the bright side, its low power rating means that it consumes less energy and thus, very energy efficient.
In terms of size, this unit has a small footprint that makes it easy to fit in tight spaces on the countertop. A small BPA free and dishwasher safe 20-ounce blending bottle comes with the blender, and it can be used as a to-go cup as well for convenience.
For safety purposes, just in case you accidentally try to blend very hard ingredients inside, the blender features a resettable fuse, which shuts off the motor when it overheats, then restores it to continue running after 15 minutes, ensuring that it has cooled down before reuse.
On the downside, this product only has a single speed setting with no presets, but this makes it easy to use due to its quick and convenient one-touch blending action.
4. Vitamix 5200 – Most Powerful Protein Shake Blender
- Power: 1490 Watts
- Speed: 10 speed
- Cup size: 64 ounces
- Material: Plastic
Vitamix’s 5200 is a very expensive blender but it has the qualities and defining features that make Vitamix blenders some of the best in the market.
For instance, this unit has the most powerful motor in this review, with a rating of 2 horsepower or roughly 1490 watts. This power essentially means that crushing through tough ice and hard, frozen fruits is a breeze.
When making protein shakes, this power is more than enough to blend any ingredients that you place inside in seconds.
In terms of control, this appliance is very versatile, featuring 10 variable speeds that are easily set using a turn dial. This dial can be rotated at any point during the blend and this enables you to adjust the drink’s texture midway through the process, meaning that you are in complete control.
Capacity wise, a large 64-ounce blending jar comes with the 5200, enabling you to make smoothy, puree, hot soup and protein shake servings for the whole family in one round.
Other features include a cool running motor, hardened stainless steel blades and a metal drive system for durability and efficient transfer of power from the motor to the blades. Combined, all these make this unit the top-rated blender for protein shakes in this review.
5. Cuisinart CPB-300 – Best Blender Set for Protein Shakes
- Power: 350 Watts
- Speed: 2 speed
- Cup size: 8, 16, 32 ounces
- Material: Plastic
Cuisinart’s CPB-300 is a very compact blender that features a 350-watt motor in a small footprint motor base and a sleek electronic touchpad that is very easy to use, having only 3 touch buttons.
Two of these buttons are for setting either the high or low speed while the third is for the pulse setting. All have LED indicators that show which of the three buttons (setting) is active.
A safety interlock feature, on the other hand, powers on the blender and lights up the power-on LED light only when the blending cup is attached for safety purposes.
However, what stands out the most about this product is that it comes as a very large set consisting of a 32-ounce blender cup, an 8-ounce chopper cup, and four 16-ounce to go cups, all with lids, making it the ideal product for blending drinks for a traveling family.
These cups are all BPA free and dishwasher safe, which makes them safe to use and very easy to maintain.
6. Hamilton Beach 51101BA – Best Personal Blender for Protein Shakes
- Power: 175 Watts
- Speed: 1 speed
- Cup size: 14 ounces
- Material: Plastic
If you are looking for a personal protein shake blender that is simply designed and fits only your individual needs, Hamilton Beach’s 51101BA is a good option to consider.
For starters, the unit is very affordable and comes with a 14-ounce blending cup that can also be used as a portable travel cup, and is designed to fit most car cup-holders.
In terms of power, a less powerful but highly energy efficient 175-watt motor is fitted into the motor base and this provides just the right amount of torque to blend through the various ingredients that make up protein shakes.
Speed wise, only a pulse speed setting is available. This may not be as versatile as the other multiple speed blenders, but it is very simple to use.
Other features include a BPA free plastic jar construction and easy to maintain, dishwasher safe parts.
7. Hamilton Beach 58148A – Best Blender for Smoothies
- Power: 700 Watts
- Speed: 3 speed
- Cup size: 40 ounces
- Material: Glass
As compared to the personal Hamilton Beach blender above, this unit is bigger, better and suitable for small family use. This is because it features a mid-sized pitcher, with a capacity of 40 ounces, and this is just enough to serve 3 – 4 people.
In terms of power, the blender features a relatively powerful 700-watt motor, which has the required torque to crush through protein shake ingredients with ease, as well as ice and other hard fruits for making purees and smoothies.
3 speeds are used to control the motor’s output and are set into 12 different blending functions that include mix, milkshake and easy clean in one speed, puree, smoothie and icy drink in the other speed and lastly, dice, chop, salsa, grind, grate and crush ice in a pulse speed.
On the upper part, a glass jar is used for blending and it requires careful handling because glass is very fragile.
This pitcher creates a wave action that pulls down the ingredients for a smooth and even blending and is coupled with a no-mess pouring spout, which ensures that the contents poured from the jar are easy to collect in a cup or container after blending.
How to Buy the Best Blenders for Protein Shakes
1. Immersion or Countertop
There are two main types of blenders to consider for making protein shakes. These are immersion blenders and countertop blenders.
Immersion blenders have the benefit of being very compact, affordable and very convenient for small blending tasks. However, they are usually weaker than countertop blenders and as such, can only be used to beat eggs, make whipped cream and protein shakes.
On the other hand, countertop blenders are more powerful, have larger blades and some feature extra functionalities for making some of the most common drinks automatically. On the downside, they are very costly and occupy sort of a permanent space on your kitchen countertop.
Buying guide: The more powerful the blender, the better. For this reason, countertop blenders are the best ones to buy. However, if you are on a tight budget, you can consider buying an immersion blender, but it must be a powerful one.
2. Type of Protein Shake
A protein shake type is determined by what you include as ingredients. If you only mix water and protein powders, you can use less powerful blenders or even a protein shake bottle to form the mix.
However, if you include fruits, veggies, and other ingredients into your shake, you will need a more powerful blender to completely smoothen out all these into liquid form.
3. Cup Size
Cup or jar size is a very important factor to consider because it determines the protein shake quantity that you can make in one round. This quantity then determines the servings that you can give.
For instance, a blending jar with a capacity of over 60 ounces is great for blending drinks for a large family while medium sized 40 – 50-ounce containers are ideal for small families. Cup sizes of less than 30 ounces are only fit for personal use because they make a very small serving.
Using this rough guide, you should buy the most appropriate unit to suit your needs.
In terms of material, the blending cup/ jar construction is considered. The most common construction material is plastic and this is because it is strong and durable. Glass is also used to make blending jars because it does not scratch or discolor over time.
On the downside, glass is very fragile and thus, if you have youngsters in the house or you are generally clumsy, go for the plastic jug unit. Otherwise, a glass jar can do.
All blenders usually come as complete sets, with the motor base and pitcher. However, some units may have additional items such as tampers for pushing the ingredients down toward the spinning blades or multiple cups for blending or grinding different quantities of food.
The more the accessories, the more you should consider buying such a product. However, ensure that you also consider the cost factor. At times these accessories may cause the blender to become very expensive and if this is the case, avoid buying such a blender.
6. Ease of Use and Cleaning
Being an electrical appliance, a blender that is easy to use is universally better than one with a complex control panel. The one that is easy to clean is also better because it will be much easier to maintain hygiene while using it.
For these reasons, you should look for a protein-shake blender with a very intuitive control panel, fewer buttons, self-cleaning functions, and a dishwasher-safe approval.
As compared to other blended drinks such as smoothies and purees, protein shakes generally require less blending power and thus, all the products reviewed above can be comfortably used to make this drink.
However, there are a few defining features that differentiate these units from one another, but with the information given above, you should have an easier time picking the best blender for protein shakes that suits your needs