10 Best Butter Dishes – Reviews & Buying Guide
In order to keep butter clean and fresh for long, it is essential to have the best butter dish. Butter dishes have been designed with airtight lids to keep butter at room temperature and fresh.
The butter dishes are made using different materials like glass, plastic, ceramic, porcelain, stoneware, and stainless steel.
Additionally, butter dishes are also of varied sizes and designs. There are smaller sizes for storing a single butter stick while larger sizes hold up two butter sticks.
Here we help make it easier to choose one with review of 10 top-rated options and a comprehensive buyer's guide.
- 10 Best Butter Dishes – Reviews
- 1. OXO 11122500 – Best Overall
- 2. Rubbermaid 1777193 – Spacious Butter Dish with Integrated Markings
- 3. KooK 1000 – Best Ceramic Butter Cover
- 4. MyGift TB-KIT0038AQUA – Stylish and Functional
- 5. Prepworks by Progressive GBD-2 – Convenient and Highly Durable
- 6. Arc International 41171 – Hygienic and Wash Resistant Butter Dish
- 7. Norpro 8370 – Elegant, Kitchen Decor-Complementing Butter Dish
- 8. Norpro 282 – Super Tough Stainless Steel Butter Dish
- 9. Sweese 3153 – Larger Capacity and Versatile Butter Dish
- 10. Mara Stoneware Collectible Butter Dish – Unique and Distinctive Handcrafted Butter Dish
- How to Buy the Best Butter Dish
10 Best Butter Dishes – Reviews
1. OXO 11122500 – Best Overall
- Size: 7.9 x 2.6 x 2 inches
- Material: Plastic
With a size of 7.9 x 2.6 x 2 inches, it is a spacious butter dish that can accommodate both short and long butter sticks. It has been perfectly designed with stoppers on either side that hinders the butter from slipping off when being transported.
More interestingly, butter dish that has been built from BPA-free plastic material, which makes it highly durable for long-term performance. Since it is BPA-free, the butter dish is very safe for keeping the butter.
The dish has a clear lid that rests on it without sliding off. It is an easy to remove and never gets dirt since it doesn’t come in contact with the butter. The crystal clear finish of the lid brings quality class to the breakfast table.
A convenient tablespoon has been incorporated in the dish for easy measurements. The dish also has measurement markings on the side for easy cutting.
The dishwasher safe butter dish is elementary to clean for long-term use.
The only notable shortcoming with this butter dish is that it will not hold cheese well. But, this is only a drawback for those that prefer something versatile they can also use for cheese.
2. Rubbermaid 1777193 – Spacious Butter Dish with Integrated Markings
- Size: 7.8 x 3.1 x 2.1 inches
- Material: Thick plastic
Having a size of 7.8 x 3.1 x 2.1 inches, it is a spacious butter dish that you can use for keeping the longer and shorter butter sticks. With the integrated markings, it allows for precise cuts.
Second, to this, the butter dish has been constructed from a quality and thick plastic material for extended use. The plastic is BPA-free, which makes it healthy for keeping the butter.
Equipped with a crystal clear lid, you can easily see the butter plus allows for safe transportation of the butter without slipping off. It has been fully secured on the base to keep the butter safe.
The affordable butter dish is dishwasher safe, which makes it convenient to clean.
Although the lip on the base that helps to ensure you get a good seal makes it hard to get a clean cut, but this is only a minor drawback and hence not a big concern.
3. KooK 1000 – Best Ceramic Butter Cover
- Size: 7.5 x 3.75 x 3.5 inches
- Material: Durable ceramic
Due to the creative and cute design, this is an amazing butter dish that suits both traditional and modern kitchen settings. It has a size of 7.5 x 3.75 x 3.5 inches, which perfectly suits it for different sizes of butter sticks.
Amazingly, it has been designed from a quality and durable ceramic material, which makes it a perfect replacement for your plastic butter dishes. The construction makes it highly durable and attractive.
The handle-fitted lid allows for easy lifting and covering of the butter. It is a versatile butter dish that you can use when baking, cooking or needs to store the extra butter.
The dishwasher safe butter dish makes it ergonomic and faster to clean it when necessary. Besides butter, it is appropriate for keeping chocolates and cheeses.
It is a relatively costly butter dish and since it is made from ceramic, the lid isn’t transparent but the price is typical of a high-quality butter dish and hence not a deal breaker.
4. MyGift TB-KIT0038AQUA – Stylish and Functional
- Size: 6.5 x 4 x 4 inches
- Material: Ceramic
Featuring a lovely bird decoration on top that doubles as a lid, it is a fantastic butter dish that will keep meals stylish and store butter safely. The size of the butter dish is 6.5 x 4 x 4 inches, which perfectly suits it for different butter sticks.
Crafted from the highest quality of ceramic material, it delivers long-term performance and will perfectly suit your kitchen settings. Designed in various colors, you can always find that favorite color for the kitchen décor.
The lid cover with decorative perched bird makes it convenient to open and cover the dish. The airtight lid ensures that the butter is safe in the dish.
Moreover, the elegant and compact design of the dish perfectly adds vibrant color and class to your kitchen counter and breakfast table.
One drawback about the dish is the smaller storage capacity which doesn’t fit the larger sticks plus the cost but it makes up for both with its eye-catching look and quality
5. Prepworks by Progressive GBD-2 – Convenient and Highly Durable
- Size: 2.9 x 6.5 x 2.5 inches
- Material: Plastic
The size of the butter dish is 2.9 x 6.5 x 2.5 inches, which perfectly suits it for the medium and smaller sized butter sticks. The good news is that the butter dish has markings on both sides for convenient measurements.
The durable butter dish is built from quality plastic material, which makes it excellent for long-term use. Apart from this, the material is also BPA-free, which suits it for storing the butter.
More interestingly, it has an airtight silicone transparent seal, which aids in keeping the butter fresh for longer. It is convenient to store in different places including a kitchen table, counter, fridge or pantry.
The patented design of the butter dish perfectly suits it for any kitchen setting. In addition to this, it is a dishwasher safe butter dish that is convenient to clean.
Even though it has a smaller storage capacity, it will always keep the butter fresh for longer.
6. Arc International 41171 – Hygienic and Wash Resistant Butter Dish
- Size: 6.7 x 4.1 x 2.8 inches
- Material: Glass
Here is a water-resistant butter dish that will guarantee the safety of the butter. With a size of 6.7 x 4.1 x 2.8 inches suits it for storing different sizes of butter sticks. It can store up to two butter sticks conveniently.
The butter dish has been constructed from quality glass material, which makes it elegant and long-lasting. You can, therefore, safely store the butter since it is 100% hygienic.
Featuring a transparent airtight lid, it is a convenient butter dish that will keep the butter fresh for long as it keeps the butter at the room temperature. You can also easily lift the lid thanks to the detailed cow design.
Due to the sleek and compact design, the dish is ideal for use in every kitchen counter and convenient to store.
Despite not being dishwasher safe, it is water-resistant, which makes the cleaning easier. The glass material makes it a little more fragile but with a little extra care it should still last long enough.
7. Norpro 8370 – Elegant, Kitchen Decor-Complementing Butter Dish
- Size: 7.5 x 3.75 x 3 inches
- Material: White porcelain
Due to the classic design, this is an elegant butter dish that will coordinate both modern and traditional kitchen décors. Apart from this, it has a large size of 7.5 x 3.75 x 3 inches and, therefore can accommodate more than a butter stick.
It has been crafted from white porcelain material, which makes it perfect for keeping the butter fresh and cool. More interestingly, the built also assures long-term service plus adds a great look in your kitchen counter.
The top knob lid allows for easy gripping to easily open and cover the dish. This makes it a user-friendly dish that will perfectly suit your kitchen.
Being a top-rack dishwasher safe butter dish, it is elementary to clean and maintain. The interior of the dish has been perfectly ridged to hinder the butter from sliding and, therefore, less mess.
Since it is made from porcelain, the lid isn’t transparent but this is hardly a significant drawback as it does not affect its usefulness.
8. Norpro 282 – Super Tough Stainless Steel Butter Dish
- Size: 7.5 x 4 x 2.5 inches
- Material: Stainless steel
This is an attractive, simple, and elegant butter dish that adds both class and elegance to your breakfast table. It has a size of 7.5 x 4 x 2.5 inches and, therefore, a versatile dish that suits longer and shorter butter sticks. The dish fits a block of cream cheese or two sticks of butter.
Second, to this, the butter dish is built from the highest quality of stainless steel material, which makes it attractive and durable. It is also rust and corrosion resistant, which suits it for the kitchen counter.
The handheld lid provides a very secure grip for an elementary opening and closing of the dish. The lid is large enough, which implies that it doesn’t touch the butter to avoid a mess. The airtight lid will keep the butter at room temperature.
The elegantly polished serving tray will always keep the bitter fresh and clean all times. Apart from butter, it is also suited for keeping the cheese.
The affordable butter dish has a compact design that will perfectly suit your kitchen space.
Hand wash is recommended as the butter dish isn’t dishwasher safe plus it is a bit heavier in weight. But for a stainless steel these are expected drawback and should hence not be the deal breakers.
9. Sweese 3153 – Larger Capacity and Versatile Butter Dish
- Size: 7.3 x 4.7 x 4.3 inches
- Material: Porcelain and beech wood
The large size of 7.3 x 4.7 x 4.3 inches, makes it a convenient butter dish that can hold up to two sticks of butter. It features a unique pattern and elegant design to brighten up the dining table.
Carefully crafted from porcelain and beech wood material, it is a fantastic butter dish that will serve for years and adds great elegance to the kitchen. And it is also quite versatile because besides using it to hold other things like cheese the lid cut also act as a chopping board.
Equipped with an airtight beech wooden lid, the butter dish will keep the butter fresh for long without having to keep in refrigerators. The ring seal ensures that air doesn’t escape from the dish for a fresh butter every time.
Hand wash with warm water is recommended whenever butter gets to stick on the side of the dish.
The high cost of the butter dish reflects the high-quality and hence not and despite not being dishwasher safe it is still easy to wash.
10. Mara Stoneware Collectible Butter Dish – Unique and Distinctive Handcrafted Butter Dish
- Size: 8 x 6 x 4 inches
- Material: Stoneware
One unique thing about this butter dish is the large and spacious interior. It has a size of 8 x 6 x 4 inches, which perfectly suits two longer butter sticks.
The hand-etched and hand-painted butter dish has been designed from quality stoneware material. This is the reason it offers long-term performances and adds a great look in every kitchen setting. The elegant, durable, and whimsical dish can be used as a decorative art as well as a dining butter dish.
The ergonomically shaped lid is easy to open and cover when needed. It features a dragonfly design, which brings out that sophisticated look.
Moreover, it is a microwave and oven safe dish that is ideal for baking, cooking, and storing butter. In addition to this, it is also dishwasher safe for convenient cleaning.
It is the most expensive butter dish in our list though highly durable. The lid is not airtight to keep butter fresh for long but if you are not planning to leave the butter in there for an extended period this should not be an issue.
How to Buy the Best Butter Dish
Here are few important factors to consider when shopping for the best butter dish.
The sizes of the butter dishes do vary from one brand to another. There are smaller sizes that can only accommodate a single butter stick while some can accommodate up to two butter sticks.
When you wish to keep more than a single butter stick, you find a relatively larger size that offers an adequate room and limits the mess.
However, when you need to keep a single shorter butter stick, you need to find a medium-sized butter dish with a large lid to prevent the mess.
For a big family, you will definitely need a larger butter dish while for personal use, consider the smaller sizes.
Just like size, the butter dishes have different designs to choose from and, therefore, you need to get the best butter keeper for your space.
First, when you wish to keep your butter clean and fresh for long at the room temperature, check for a butter dish designed with an airtight seal.
Secondly, for a more practical design, you should try out butter dishes with transparent lid made of plastic or glass like Rubbermaid 1777193.
More interestingly, for a better vintage appearance in the kitchen décor, consider a butter dish designed to emulate the original French butter crock.
Lastly, for a contemporary look, you should consider a butter bay or butter boat dish.
The butter dishes have been constructed from different material including plastic, metal, porcelain, glass, and stoneware. This implies that they have different lifespans and weights among other things.
The plastic butter dishes are not highly durable but lightweight and transparent. They are also safe from BPA material, making then suitable for keeping the butter.
For the glass butter dishes like Arc International 41171, they are also transparent but heavier and may scratch with time. They don’t contain cadmium and lead, making them safe.
The metallic butter dishes are known to be durable but kind of heavier. However, they are safe since they don’t contain non-toxic materials.
The ceramic, stoneware, and porcelain butter dishes are also durable and feature in unique designs with decorations, making them great for any kitchen décor.
All the butter dishes have lids for keeping the butter safe. You, therefore, need to get the best butter dish with a lid that will serve you longer.
4. Ease to Clean
Since some butter dishes are dishwasher safe while others are hand wash, you need to find the best pick that will suit you.
The dishwasher safe butter dishes are elementary and quick to clean, unlike the hand wash. However, when you need a hand wash butter dish, ensure that all parts can easily be cleaned and is also water-resistant.
Shopping for the best butter dish should now be an effortless job as it is all about choosing one from our top 10 reviews above.
And from our reviews, the OXO 11122500 takes the top spot as our best overall recommendation as besides accommodating both short and tall sticks it is also well-built.
The Mara Stoneware Collectible Butter Dish, on the other hand, is our recommendation for those looking for something unique and spacious that will look amazing in any kitchen.