7 Best Butter Keepers of 2021 Compared & Reviewed

Best Butter Keeper
Photo: Trudeau

Spreadable and fresh butter on hot toast is a morning routine for most people around the globe. Additionally, it is a pleasant and healthy way to start the day. Unfortunately for some people, they have to deal hard refrigerated butter that ends up tearing the slice of bread.

To avoid this, you should in the best butter keeper on the market. This is an important item that helps to keep butter soft, sweet, spreadable and fresh at room temperature.

If you are thinking of investing in one, here is an in-depth buying guide and 7 best butter keeper reviews to help you make an informed decision.

What To Check Before Buying Best Butter Keeper?

How to Buy the Best Butter Keeper
Photo: SveBake

1. Size and Shape

Butter keepers feature varying shapes and sizes. For this reason, their capacity also differs. Therefore, the best size of butter keeper for you to buy should be determined by the amount of butter you consume.

If you seldom consume butter, buy a butter keeper of a small size as this will only store less butter. However, if you are a large family that consumes butter frequently, invest in a butter keeper of a larger size and possibly, one that can accommodate more than 1 butter stick.

When it comes to shapes, you should buy the one that best matches your taste. 

2. Material

There are various materials that make butter keepers. The most common materials that you will find on the market today, include: Earthenware, marble, stainless steel, glass, stoneware, and plastic.

Stoneware

When buying a stoneware made butter keeper, always make sure that it is coated using non-porous glaze. This is because absorbent surfaces like terracotta can lead to the development of bacteria after soaking up the butter.

Stainless Steel and Plastic

Single wall stainless steel and plastic butter keepers do not offer adequate insulation to your butter. As a result, your butter can melt because of getting too warm.

Therefore, when buying a stainless steel or plastic butter keeper, always buy a double-walled product and this prevents the interiors from becoming warm. 

Earthenware and Marble

These two materials are very good when it comes to protecting butter from varying temperatures. This is because the materials are insulated naturally, and so they usually maintain cooler interior temperatures as compared to that of the surrounding environment.

Glass material is also great as it features adequate insulation bearing in mind that it is thick.

In case the butter keeper you buy comes with a wooden lid, it is wise to ensure that it does not get in touch with butter.

3. Easy to Clean

Butter keepers should be clearly cleaned after stored butter is used up. This helps to inhibit the development of bacteria and mold. You can either handwash butter keepers or use a dishwasher if they are safe for that.

Numerous butter keepers that are made using porcelain, plastic, glass, and metal are dishwasher safe and this makes them easy to clean. However, some handmade pottery butter keepers may need you to handwash them using warm and soapy water.

Butter keepers that feature bamboo or wooden lids may require you to remove the lid before using a dishwasher on them. The lids should be hand washed and quickly dried to inhibit chances of soaking and warping.

7 Best Butter Keepers of 2021 Reviewed

IMAGEPRODUCTFEATURES
OXO 111224001. OXO 11122400 (Best for Mess-Free Use)
  • 2 stoppers for mess-free use
  • Premium quality stainless steel material enhancing longevity
  • BPA-free plastic lid for clear viewing
  • Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning
Butter Bell BB-AQSS2. Butter Bell BB-AQSS (Best Ceramic Design)
  • Highly durable ceramic material
  • Stylish and practical design
  • 2-piece design for storing and protecting butter
  • Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning
Sweese 31093. Sweese 3109 (Vibrant Array of Colors)
  • Vibrant array of colors to choose from
  • Pro-grade porcelain material
  • Gorgeous patterns makes it an attractive addition to any space
  • Dishwasher safe hence, minimal care
Le Creuset PG0200-09674. Le Creuset PG0200-0967 (Best Stain-Resistant)
  • Stain-resistant from stoneware material
  • Non-porous enameled glaze
  • Dishwasher safe makes it easy to clean
  • User-friendly design that keeps you away from guessing
SveBake ButterDishes45. SveBake ButterDishes4 (Best Classic)
  • Classic product from its contemporary but vintage design
  • Beech wood lid with simple but functional design
  • Attractive navy blue rim makes it stylish
  • Enamel glaze for easy cleaning
NorPro 278A6. NorPro 278A (Best Marble Design)
  • High quality marble material
  • Keeps butter fresh and soft for 30 days
  • Compact design for convenient storage
Trudeau 09607081A7. Trudeau 09607081A (Best Uniquely-Designed)
  • Unique dual chamber design
  • High quality glazed porcelain material
  • Classic white color gives elegant look
  • Dishwasher safe makes simple to clean

1. OXO 11122400 – Best Mess-Free

OXO 11122400
Photo: OXO

  • Size: 7.9 x 2.6 x 2 Inches
  • Material: Stainless Steel

OXO 11122400 is a mess-free butter keeper and this is highly enhanced by the stoppers on either side of the product. These stoppers always ensure that your butter is in place when you are cutting it. Therefore, there are no chances of butter slipping and so you will always have clean slices.

The product is known to be the best butter keeper because it is made using premium quality materials. Its base features a stainless steel material that is rust resistant. This material gives the butter keeper a sleek look making it tough enough for the kitchen and elegant enough for the table.

Additionally, this butter keeper also features a BPA-free plastic lid which is clear and allows you to view right through it. The lid is easily removable and the great thing about it is that it does not slide off the butter keeper.

The product is dishwasher safe and this implies that the butter keeper is easy to clean. Hence, it will not take much of your time and effort when cleaning after butter is over.

The butter keeper is long enough to accommodate long butter pieces, but it should be tall enough to avoid smearing the lid with butter.

Pros:

  • Quick cleaning as it is dishwasher safe
  • Mess-free as it produces clean butter pieces
  • Rust-resistant stainless steel material
  • Easy to remove clear lid

Cons:

  • Should be an inch taller to prevent butter from smearing the lid
  • Limited color options

2. Butter Bell BB-AQSS – Best Ceramic Butter Keeper

Butter Bell BB-AQSS
Photo: Butter Bell

  • Size: 3.5 x 3.5 x 4.2 Inches
  • Material: New Bone China Clay

Butter Bell BB-AQSS features the best ceramic butter keeper because it contains a high-grade ceramic mixture of liquid new bone china clay. This material makes this product highly durable and comes with a scratch resistant finish.

You will love the stylish and practical design of this butter keeper as it is conveniently sized to fit neatly on the countertop. Additionally, it comes with an elegant design that gives it an ideal accent to accentuate any tabletop or kitchen décor.

This is a 2-piece product that perfectly stores and protects your butter after every use. Butter Bell BB-AQSS is designed to keep butter spreadable and fresh for several weeks without odors, spoilage or refrigeration.

The product is also dishwasher safe and this implies that it is easy to clean and maintain. Nonetheless, you must handle this butter keeper with a lot of care to avoid dropping it.

Pros:

  • Lots of colors available to choose from
  • Polishes the look of your kitchen and table-top
  • Easy to clean
  • Keeps butter fresh and spreadable for long

Cons:

  • Requires you to change the water every few days
  • Proper and careful handling is recommended

3. Sweese 3109 – Vibrant Array of Colors

Sweese 3109
Photo: Sweese

  • Size: 6.2 x 5.4 x 5.3 Inches
  • Material: Porcelain

Here is a butter keeper that features a vibrant array of colors for you to choose from. Therefore, it ensures that you will find a color that will match your tabletop and kitchen décor perfectly.

The reason why most butter lovers consider this is the best French butter keeper available is because of its pro-grade porcelain material it is made of. Its material is non-toxic, chip-resistant and highly sturdy to ensure that it is stable during use.

Additionally, you will also love the gorgeous patterns that come with this butter keeper. Apart from being well-made, this product is beautifully finished with amazing patterns, making it an attractive addition to your table or kitchen.

Most people love this butter keeper because it is easy to use and wash. The product washes well in the dishwasher and also requires minimal care.

This butter keeper comes with the capacity of keeping butter fresh for a month, but this requires you to change the water every day or in every couple of days.

Pros:

  • Enough capacity for most families
  • Non-toxic and lead-free material
  • Easy to use and maintain
  • Beautifully finished and chip-resistant

Cons:

  • A little heavyweight
  • You might have to buy 2 for a large family

4. Le Creuset PG0200-0967 – Best Stain-Resistant

Le Creuset PG0200-0967
Photo: Le Creuset

  • Size: 4 x 4 x 4.5 Inches
  • Material: Stoneware

This is a stain resistant butter keeper, which means that its stoneware material cannot get stains. Additionally, it has been designed in such a way that it is chip resistant and also cannot attract any odors. Hence, this product is one of the best for use at the table.

The product is made using high-fired stoneware and a non-porous enameled glaze. With such a combination, you can be sure that this butter keeper will always keep your butter fresh and soft without refrigeration. Moreover, the product cannot scratch or crack, making it highly durable.

To make it easy to clean, this butter keeper is a dishwasher safe. The fact that it features a stoneware material means that there are several colors available that you can pick from.

What makes this the best butter keeper with water is its user-friendliness implying that with it, you do not have to keep guessing where water should reach because it features a water line in the crock, indicating how much water should be poured in it.

Even though you can be sure that this butter keeper provides an airtight seal, butter can still fall into the water if you fail to properly pack the bell.

Pros:

  • High fired material keeps product from stains, scratches, and cracks
  • Resistant to odor absorption
  • Has a lifetime warranty
  • Quick cleaning – non-porous enameled glazed interior

Cons:

  • Relatively expensive but worth the investment
  • Proper butter packing should be done to maintain an airtight seal

5. SveBake ButterDishes4 – Best Classic

SveBake ButterDishes4
Photo: SveBake

  • Size: 6.1 x 3.9 x 2.6 Inches
  • Material: Enamel

This is the most classic butter keeper because of its contemporary but vintage design that is promoted by its white color finish and the beech wood lid it comes with. It gives an exquisite look as the product is also cutely sized.

The beech wood lid that comes with this butter keeper is made from a pure and natural wood material with a unique set of grains that gives it an elegant look. It’s a simple lid but one that is highly functional because you can also use it as a serving board or a chopping board.

What makes SveBake ButterDishes4 the best butter dish is the fact that it features an attractive rim of navy blue color and the word butter on it. This makes the butter keeper stylish counter addition and a perfect gift for any foodie or loved one.

Its enamel glaze only requires some warm water to make it sparkling clean, but you have to remove the lid in order for it to be dishwasher safe.

Pros:

  • Can store 2 butter sticks
  • Perfect for storing both cream and block butter
  • Contemporary but vintage look
  • Multifunctional design adding value to your kitchen

Cons:

  • Not dishwasher safe with the lid on

6. NorPro 278A – Best Marble

NorPro 278A
Photo: NorPro

  • Size: 4 x 3.8 x 3.8 Inches
  • Material: Marble

This is the best marble butter keeper because it not only features an attractive look but also ensures that your butter remains cool naturally. It features patterns and colors that slightly vary and so you can be sure that it makes a stunning addition on your tabletop or in your kitchen.

For up to 30 days, this butter keeper will keep your butter fresh, sweet, soft and spreadable without refrigeration. Additionally, it is easy to use, implying that it can be used by anyone in the family.

The product comes with a compact design and this allows you to conveniently place it at the table without covering a very large area. Additionally, you can easily pass it around the table without creating any mess.

NorPro 278Ais easy to clean as it only requires some warm, soapy water to keep it sparkling clean. Nonetheless, it is recommendable that you hand-wash it, as it is not dishwasher friendly.

Pros:

  • Has a space-saving design
  • Has an attractive marble construction
  • Fairly priced to give you value
  • Numerous patterns available

Cons:

  • Not dishwasher recommended
  • A little heavy hence requires care handling

7. Trudeau 09607081A – Best Uniquely-Designed

Trudeau 09607081A
Photo: Trudeau

  • Size: 8.3 x 3.9 x 3.8 Inches
  • Material:  Porcelain

This Trudeau butter keeper comes with a unique design which you cannot find in other butter keepers on the market.

The product features a dual chamber, where butter is stored in the boat while cold water is accommodated by the basin under the boat. However, this product uses the same mechanism.

The product is made using glazed porcelain material of high quality. As a result, this product will serve you for a prolonged period of time, giving you amazing value for your investment. Additionally, with the help of this material, butter remains spreadable, soft and fresh.

It features a classic white color that gives it an elegant look that adds a look and feel of sophistication in your kitchen. Moreover, its look also polished the look of your tabletop.

This Trudeau product is dishwasher safe and this makes it easy to clean. However, even if the product is uniquely design, this product has a small handle that is unsuitable for people with large hands.

Pros:

  • Unique design gives it a characteristic look
  • Can fit a couple of butter sticks
  • Easy to clean as it is dishwasher safe
  • Matches any décor – Classic white design 

Cons:

  • Requires more space on the table or on the kitchen counter
  • The handle is small for people with large hands

Conclusion 

Buying a butter keeper requires you to make an informed and clear decision. The above buying guide and butter keeper reviews should help you with your decision-making process. Products in the review section feature high-quality and most of them also feature superior durability.

Since they come with different colors and sizes and shapes, pick the best that matches your lifestyle, budget, taste, and need.