10 Best Cookie Sheets – Reviews & Buying Guide
When you need you need to bake all your favorite cookies, it starts by investing in the ultimate cookie sheet.
Cookie sheets are made from either aluminum or stainless steel material for even heat distribution and extended performances.
Again, the cookie sheets are non-slip for easy cleaning and effortless release of the cookies without breaking it.
Featuring side handles, you can comfortably hold the cookie sheets when taking on and off the oven.
To find your favorite cookie sheet, these below picks summarizes different cookies based on material, budget, sizes, and color to choose from.
- 10 Best Cookie Sheets – Reviews
- 1. Nordic Ware Cookie Sheet – Extra-large Sheet Pan
- 2. OXO Cookie Sheet – Micro-textured, Non-stick Pattern
- 3. USA Pan Cookie Sheet – Unique Fluted Design
- 4. Vollrath 68085 – Two Curved Sides, Two Flat Sides
- 5. AirBake 84820 – Micro-dome Technology
- 6. Good Cook 04322 – Best Budget
- 7. GRIDMANN Cookie Sheet – 6 Sheet Pans
- 8. T-Fal 84812 – Air Insulated
- 9. Baker’s Secret Cookie Sheet – Even Heat Distribution
- 10. Wilton Cookie Sheets – Oversized Handles
- How to Buy the Best Cookie Sheet
10 Best Cookie Sheets – Reviews
1. Nordic Ware Cookie Sheet (Extra-Large Sheet Pan)
2. OXO Cookie Sheet (Micro-Textured, Non-Stick Pattern)
3. USA Pan Cookie Sheet (Unique Fluted Design)
4. Vollrath 68085 (Two Curved Sides, Two Flat Sides)
5. AirBake 84820 (Micro-Dome Technology)
6. Good Cook 04322 (Best Budget)
7. GRIDMANN Cookie Sheet (6 Sheet Pans)
8. T-fal 84812 (Air Insulated)
9. Baker’s Secret Cookie Sheet (Even Heat Distribution)
10. Wilton Cookie Sheets (Oversized Handles)
1. Nordic Ware Cookie Sheet
(Extra-Large Sheet Pan)
2. OXO Cookie Sheet
(Micro-Textured, Non-Stick Pattern)
3. USA Pan Cookie Sheet
(Unique Fluted Design)
4. Vollrath 68085
(Two Curved Sides, Two Flat Sides)
5. AirBake 84820
6. Good Cook 04322
7. GRIDMANN Cookie Sheet
(6 Sheet Pans)
8. T-fal 84812
9. Baker’s Secret Cookie Sheet
(Even Heat Distribution)
10. Wilton Cookie Sheets
1. Nordic Ware Cookie Sheet – Extra-large Sheet Pan
- Size: 21 x 15 x 1inches
- Material: Rust-proof aluminum and galvanized steel
When you wish to make mega batches of cookies, Nordic Ware is the largest unit on our list. The good thing is that the cookie sheet fits all standard size ovens. The overall size is 21 x 15 x 1 inches, which is a 35% larger surface compared to the half sheet.
Moreover, the quality built of the cookie sheet guarantees both durability and quality in equal measures. The rust-proof aluminum material brings about even heat distribution for the enhanced cooking process. For added strength, the rims are reinforced with galvanized steel.
That said, with the quality non-stick properties, it allows for easy release of the cookies. The big sheet can be used with wood, silicone, and nylon utensils.
For longer life, Nordic Ware needs to be hand-washed instead of dishwashing. In addition to this, the pack only contains a single cookie sheet.
2. OXO Cookie Sheet – Micro-textured, Non-stick Pattern
- Size: 14.5 x 18.5 x 0.4 inches
- Material: Heavy-grade aluminized steel
With OXO, you get to bake tasty cookies thanks to the micro-textured non-stick patterns. This aids in enhancing the airflow plus reduces the surface contact for even baking. Additionally, it has a size of 14.5 x 18.5 x 0.4 inches for baking different cookie sizes.
Second, to this, the bakeware is a product of heavy-grade aluminized steel material. The good thing about the material is that it promotes even heat distribution plus improves durability.
Again, the ceramic reinforced commercial-grade double-layer PTFE non-stick coating makes it an ergonomic cookie sheet. This not only allows for easy cookie release but also makes it abrasion, corrosion, stain, and scratch-resistant.
The good news is that the sheet features square-rolled edges that bring about great strength plus a secure grip. You can, therefore, easily transfer the sheet to and from the oven.
As a single cookie sheet, OXO isn’t great for commercial purposes. It is also relatively heavier due to the double layer and heavy-grade material.
3. USA Pan Cookie Sheet – Unique Fluted Design
- Size: 18 x 14 x 0.25 inches
- Material: Heavy-gauge steel and aluminum steel
Featuring the unique corrugated surfaces, it perfectly enhances the non-stick properties. This also adds strength for great warp resistance. That said, the medium-sized cookie sheet is a great pick for family use. It measures 18 x 14 x 0.25 inches.
USA Pan has been built from the same standard of high performances from a combo of heavy-gauge steel and aluminum steel. Due to this, expect long-term performances plus durability.
You can effortlessly release the cookies off the pan thanks to the patented Americoat Plus silicone non-stick coating. This will protect both the baked treats and pans.
With the raised edge, you get a very secure and easy grip when holding the cookie sheet. This makes it elementary to handle the sheet when baking.
However, USA Pan isn’t large enough to accommodate mega cookies. The handle size is also smaller in size.
4. Vollrath 68085 – Two Curved Sides, Two Flat Sides
- Size: 17.1 x 13.7 x 0.5 inches
- Material: Heavy-gauge 3004 aluminum
The size of the cookie sheet is a consideration to look out for before making the purchase. Vollrath measures 17.1 x 13.7 x 0.5 inches to suit baking cookies of varied sizes. With two flat sides, food is easily slide off while the curved sides offer a secure grip.
More interestingly, the cookie sheet guarantees excellent services for years thanks to the heavy-gauge 3004 aluminum material. Its 10-gauge built to ensure that it is warp resistance plus promotes even heat distribution.
Besides this, the cookie sheet allows you to remove the cookies with a lot of ease once fully baked. Its improved non-stick properties easily slide the cookies off the sheet.
Apart from the single sheet pack, you can also go for the 3-pack or 6-pack sheets depending on your baking needs.
The versatile sheet is appropriate for cookies, hamburger buns, hot dog, and bread among others.
Unfortunately, Vollrath is one of the most expensive units on the list.
5. AirBake 84820 – Micro-dome Technology
- Size: 14 x 12 inches and 16 x 14 inches
- Material: Two heavyweight aluminum sheets
Utilizing micro-dome technology, AirBake is superior bakeware that will lower the bake time by about 15%. The insulated aluminum sheets greatly enhance the baking speed. The good news is that it has a great size, which makes it favorite for smaller to medium-sized cookies. The sheets have sizes of 14 x 12 inches and 16 x 14 inches.
In addition to this, its durability and performances are a match. Crafted from two heavyweight aluminum sheets, you should expect to use them for long and enhances even the cooking process.
With non-stick surfaces, cleaning of the sheets is a breeze. This also ensures that the food doesn’t stick on the surfaces for easy release.
The sheets also have bottom layers, which reduces the direct oven heat. A layer of air also hinders the top sheet from overheating.
Containing only two pieces in the pack, it is not favorite for large baking needs. The sheets should be hand-washed despite being dishwasher safe.
6. Good Cook 04322 – Best Budget
- Size: 13 x 9 inches, 15 x 10 inches, and 17 x 10 inches
- Material: Stainless steel
Even though it contains three sheets in the pack, Good Cook is the most affordable unit that suits many users. Additionally, it provides a lifetime exchange guarantee for a lifetime use. They are of graduating sizes that include 13 x 9 inches, 15 x 10 inches, and 17 x 10 inches.
Featuring updated design, the cookie sheets bring about increased durability for repeated use. Each of the sheets has been built from the highest quality of stainless steel material for enhanced conductivity.
Again, all the three pans have heavy-duty non-stick coating layers. So you get to easily slide off the cookies. This also makes cleaning easier and faster.
That said, with the small, medium, and large sheets, baking of all your favorite cookies is now simpler. The sheets are dishwasher safe for quick cleaning.
On the downside, Good Cook feature smaller side handles, which make holding the sheets kind of uncomfortable.
7. GRIDMANN Cookie Sheet – 6 Sheet Pans
- Size: 13 x 18 inches
- Material: 18-gauge commercial grade aluminum
When you need a sheet pack you can use for commercial purposes, GRIDMANN is a pick with up to six sheets. This implies that you can use it for baking more cookies at once. The six half sheets baking pans have equal dimensions of 13 x 18 inches.
Due to the 18-gauge commercial grade aluminum materials used in the construction, these are highly durable sheets that will serve you for years. The heat conduction is also at its best.
You can conveniently remove the cookies without breaking. This is because each sheet has been equipped with non-stick interiors.
For added durability, the sheets have reinforced beaded rims that hinder warping. Even though they heat quickly and evenly, the sheets also cool faster.
However, GRIDMANN is the most expensive unit that will demand you dig deeper into the pockets. In addition to this, the sheets should be hand-washed, which takes time to clean every piece.
8. T-Fal 84812 – Air Insulated
- Size: 16 x 14 x 0.3 inches
- Material: Two heavyweight aluminum steel
Baking cookies evenly without burning is now a breeze with T-Fal. The bakeware has been equipped with an air-insulated sheet that hinders cookies from burning. Besides this, the cookie sheet is great for baking cookies of medium to larger sizes with a size of 16 x 14 x 0.3 inches.
Since it has been built from the highest quality of two heavyweight aluminum steel sheets, expect top-notch performances and increased longevity.
Both cleaning the interior and release of the cookies is now elementary. This is because the cookie sheet has better non-stick surfaces to hinder food from sticking on the surfaces.
The good thing is that T-Fal utilizes micro-dome technology to lower the baking time by up to 15%.
In spite of the higher cost, the unit provides up to the 10-year warranty. The handle is located on one side, which makes holding kind of uncomfortable.
9. Baker’s Secret Cookie Sheet – Even Heat Distribution
- Size: 19.1 x 12.1 x 0.9 inches
- Material: 0.5-gauge steel
The Baker’s Secret is known for its outstanding even heat distribution. This is because of the quality 0.5-gauge steel used in the construction. With a size of 19.1 x 12.1 x 0.9 inches, the cookie sheet is great for baking larger cookies.
It's quality rugged construction brings about long-term performance plus durability. The cookie sheet is built from the best quality of heavy-gauge stainless steel. The reinforced rim sides provide a better and secure grip and strength.
With that said, you will like its premium non-stick coating that allows for easy release of the cookies. A non-stick interior implies no food sticks on it for elementary cleaning.
Again, to clean the sheet after use, throw it in the dishwasher for efficient cleaning. The unit is metal spatula safe as it won’t scratch off the coating.
Baker’s Secret pack only consists of one and two cookie sheet packs, which implies that it doesn’t fit commercial baking.
10. Wilton Cookie Sheets – Oversized Handles
- Size: 15.25 x 10.25 inches and 17.25 x 11.5 inches
- Material: Stainless steel
Equipped with large oversized handles, handling of Wilton on and off the oven is very easy. The large handles offer better and secure grips so that it doesn’t slip off. With two units in the pack of sizes 15.25 x 10.25 inches and 17.25 x 11.5 inches, you will find them favorite for your baking needs.
In addition to this, the two cookie sheets are made from durable stainless steel materials. This, therefore, extends the lifespan of the sheets for years of baking.
The high-quality cookie sheet also has non-stick surfaces. Due to this, you get to quickly clean up the sheet and also allows for easy release of the baked cookies.
In addition to the average cost, Wilton still offers up to a limited 5-year warranty for the products. These sheets are also dishwasher safe for elementary cleaning.
Unfortunately, the cookie sheets are not resistant to higher temperatures. At 450-degrees F, the sheets are likely to warp.
How to Buy the Best Cookie Sheet
When looking forward to investing in the best baking sheet, you have to check for a perfect unit that will serve you longer. This is by considering things like.
1. Types of Cookie Sheet
There are four main different types of cookie sheets to choose from. These include metal, non-stick, finish, and insulated types.
The cookie sheets have been designed from metallic materials. There are aluminum and black steel types of metal cookie sheets.
The metallic cookie sheets have been designed in a wide range of styles like edgeless, edges, and very high sides.
Again, such cookie sheets are made from thick metals like aluminum, which enhances the heat conduction for even baking.
When using the metallic cookie sheets, you should add a silicone baking sheet to prevent the negative reaction that might produce metallic flavor.
The metallic cookie sheets are also thicker and kind of heavier.
Secondly, there are non-stick cookie sheets, which are the most common types. The good thing about the non-stick cookie sheets is that they bake relatively faster. However, when overbaked, cookies might get dry.
Additionally, cleaning of such cookie sheets is a breeze since food doesn’t stick on the surfaces. The non-stick vary by composition plus color.
The finishes of the cookie sheets always vary based on the color. The color of the sheet will determine what color of cookie it produces.
For instance, the lighter finishes will bring about lighter colors in cookies. On the other hand, darker finishes will bake darker cookies.
With the insulated types of cookie sheets, we have units with a hollow space between two metal layers while some got a thin layer of air.
The insulated cookie sheets tend to bake slowly though limit the chances of burning the cookies.
In addition to this, they are perfect for cutting out sugar cookies. This is because they keep cookies kind of lightly colored.
There are smaller, medium, and larger cookie sheet. This is why you can always find your perfect cookie size depending on the sizes you wish to bake.
For the smaller sized cookie sheets, you can only use it for making the smaller cookies and, therefore, not versatile.
A good cookie sheet should be larger so that it can bake both smaller and mega cookies sizes.
Still, about the size, some packs contain more than a cookie sheet with different sizes. Such units will provide you with graduating sizes of cookie sheets.
You also need to look out for the ultimate color of the cookie sheet that will suit your baking needs.
The two common cookie sheet colors are dark and lighter. The dark-colored cookie sheets are great for baking darker cookies.
However, the lighter color cookie sheets are perfect for baking lighter cookies. You, therefore, need to choose depending on the color of cookies you need.
4. Material Construction
It is also essential to check for the type of material used in the construction of the cookie sheet. The cookie sheets are made from aluminum or stainless steel.
The aluminum cookie sheets are excellent heat conductors plus allow for even heat distribution. Such a cookie sheet will allow for quality browning of the cookies.
However, the aluminum cookie sheets are lighter and, therefore, cool faster.
The best material for cookie sheet is stainless steel. The stainless steel cookie sheets offer excellent heat distribution plus enhance stay cool for long.
Additionally, stainless steel cookie sheets are also rust and corrosion resistance for long-term performances.
When looking for a cookie sheet, check for the sides of the unit. It needs to have reinforced rim sides that provide secure handles.
With such a cookie sheet, you can easily remove and place the sheet into the oven.
To summarize, when you are a baking enthusiast, you need to invest in a top-rated cookie sheet.
The cookie sheets have been designed to bake either darker or lighter cookies depending on the color of the unit.
In addition to this, the cookie sheets have non-slip interiors for easy release of the cookies. The non-stick surfaces also allow for elementary cleaning.
They have excellent heat conductivity to make the baking process even and faster. Equipped with side handles, they are comfy and secure to hold.
From the above cookie sheet review, you will find a wide range of cookie sheets that will suit your baking needs.