Pancake griddles are deemed as the most useful appliance for making mouth-watering pancakes. Selection of the best pancake griddle is based on a couple of factors like your budget, choice of the type, material, and other close-connected factors.
Starting from aluminum to cast iron, you get a generous variety in materials. Also, not to forget the cooking surface of the appliance which can vary from 10 to 22-inches.
Well, there are plenty of big to small details that this review will help you determine and make a safe selection.
10 Best Pancake Griddles – Review
1. Presto 07061 (Best Overall)
2. Faberware 21745 (Most Affordable)
3. Lodge 17L9OG3 (Most Durable)
4. Anolon 82854 (Lifetime Warranty)
5. Black & Decker GD2051B (Extra-Large Size)
6. Presto 07047 (Low-Profile Design)
7. Zorirushi EA-DCC10 (Has a Lid)
8. Cuisinart MCP45-25NS (Tri-Ply Design)
9. Nordic Ware 1930 (Versatile)
10. Oster CKSTGRFM18W-TECO (With DuraCeramic Non-stick Coating)
1. Presto 07061
2. Faberware 21745
3. Lodge 17L9OG3
4. Anolon 82854
5. Black & Decker GD2051B
6. Presto 07047
7. Zorirushi EA-DCC10
(Has a Lid)
8. Cuisinart MCP45-25NS
9. Nordic Ware 1930
10. Oster CKSTGRFM18W-TECO
(With DuraCeramic Non-stick Coating)
1. Presto 07061 – Best Overall Pancake Griddle
- Cooking Surface: 18-inches
- Material: Plastic, Heavy Cast-Aluminum
This electric pancake griddle is the best overall product as it is high in performance and comes on a suitable price.
With the surface area of 18-inches, this model gives you enough space to make pancakes for a medium-sized family.
As far as the material is concerned, it has heavy cast aluminium base with premium non-stick coating on the top. It is completely warp-proof.
You can expect stick-free experience of making pancakes and the easy slide out drip tray helps in removing the pancakes easily from the griddle. It also helps in effortless cleaning.
There are heat control functions that allow you to increase or decrease the intensity of heat as you desire for the cooking. It is among the top-rated pancake griddles on our list.
The griddle is completely immersible as you remove all the heat controls. This means that when you are done with the cooking, you can take out the griddle and wash it with flowing water and soap. However, it is not recommended being washed in a dishwasher.
For this, you just have to open the latch clips and detach handles from the base. It does not require any special tools for the removal. With handles removed, you can easily store it anywhere in the kitchen.
- Extremely-efficient and affordably priced
- Fully immersible
- No extra tools required to detach the griddle from handles
- Comes with heat controls
- Not suggested to be washed in a dishwasher
2. Faberware 21745 – Most Affordable Pancake Griddle
- Cooking Surface: 11-inches
- Material: Aluminium
We will start with the shining point of this model which is the toughness of aluminium material. It is the most affordable product on the list.
It is scratch-free and has the potential to stay in fine shape for years. This also reminds us of the durability factor. It is a durable product that you will love to own.
Now, about the high performance, this one is a simple stovetop griddle that can be used on various temperature conditions. It is least in maintenance and handling. You can use it freely without any certain precautions.
You can put it inside a dishwasher for convenient washing or also wash it with hand. However, for more long-lasting performance, we will recommend hand wash of the griddle.
The square shape of the griddle is quite impressive and while its light weightiness is a good thing to toss the pancakes easily, some people might find it less on balancing on the stovetop.
The cooking surface is surely a disappointment because you cannot make more than one or two pancakes at a time. Certainly, this is not a recommended piece for large families.
- Most-affordable pancake griddle
- Made of tough aluminium
- Striking looks in square shape
- No special cleaning demands
- Too small in size
- Balancing concerns on the stovetop because of the lightweight
3. Lodge 17L9OG3 – Most Durable Pancake Griddle
- Cooking Surface: 10.5-inches
- Material: Cast Iron
So, if it comes down to the most conventional option then beating the Lodge cast iron griddle is next to impossible. This solid frame and construction ensures lifetime durability.
Well, this is a simple round griddle, mostly suitable for smaller families, and comes with a rigid plastic handle to hold it. Everything about this product is quite solid in performance.
Since the material used here is cast iron, you sometimes might have to struggle with the sticking batter. However, this can be overcome by pouring a suitable amount of oil on the top of the griddle and then putting on the batter.
If you like less oil in your food then you may not prefer this model because it will need extra oiling on the base.
- Lifetime durability due to cast-iron material
- Great in performance
- Suitably priced
- Batter sticks on the surface
4. Anolon 82854 – Pancake Griddle with Lifetime Warranty
- Cooking Surface: 18 x 10-inches
- Material: Anodized Aluminium
Different families have different requirements from the kitchen products they buy. This one gives full peace of mind to the buyers with lifetime warranty.
It is suitable for medium-sized families because of the cooking surface. The griddle is beautifully crafted with amazing features, starting with the hard-anodized aluminium material with deep black non-stick coating on the top.
Unlike various other models, there are no balancing concerns with this product as it is suitably weighed to firmly stand on the stovetop.
There is even distribution of heat on the griddle, and it comes with a stainless-steel turner to easily make pancakes without burning yourself.
The base is scratch-less and demands less maintenance. It is dishwasher-safe. This is an extraordinary part that you don’t necessarily have to put any special emphasis on cleaning the griddle.
You have to be very careful while buying that this product is not compatible with glass stovetop without a bridge. It is also not suitable for induction. So, make sure that you won’t be able to use the griddle on either of these two options.
Also, as per competitive products, it is quite expensive.
- Comes with lifetime warranty
- Suitable for medium-sized families
- Less in maintenance
- Comes with stainless steel turner
- On pricier side
- Not compatible with induction
5. Black & Decker GD2051B – Extra-Large Pancake Griddle
Photo: Black & Decker
- Cooking Surface: 10 x 20-inches
- Material: Plastic & Non-Stick Thermostat
Black & Decker family is renowned to produce the finest quality kitchen appliances. Well, it is a family-sized griddle with the largest size in our list.
If you have a huge family then this product will suit your needs. The cooking surface of 10 x 20-inches will help in making a large batch of pancakes in a go. You can make a batch of 8 – 10 pancakes at a time.
As far as price is concerned, this one is among those griddles that are most cost-effective, considering the fact that this is an electricity-driven product.
The surface is coated with non-stick material so that any kind of sticking on the surface can be prohibited. The cooking become really fast.
The material used here is non-stick thermostat with plastic handles so that you can pick it even when it is hot. The temperature is adjustable too.
The drip tray is removable, and you can easily drain the pancakes off the griddle with utmost convenience.
With all that said, there is a bitter pitfall to this model is that it has to be handled very carefully while cleaning. Any hard operation might just hamper the coating of the griddle.
- Quite large in size
- Priced well
- Adjustable temperature
- Removable drip tray
- Must be handled very carefully while cleaning
6. Presto 07047 – Pancake Griddle in Low Profile Design
- Cooking Surface: 10-1/2 x 16-inches
- Material: Cast Aluminium
Not every buyer has same requirements and this product will suit the needs of small families as it has a low-profile design for quick usage and storing.
This griddle is fully immersible. You can remove the casing and wash the griddle part as you like. It can either be hand washed or in a dishwasher.
The upper surface is coated with non-stick material that prevent the batter from sticking.
The material used in the making of the griddle is a heavy cast aluminium base. There are heat controls that automatically maintains the proper cooking temperature. It will take 1300-watts of energy to operate.
The slide out tray easily helps in sliding and removing the pancakes from the griddle.
On the downside, people who seek warranty with every purchase will be disappointed as this product does not come with any warranty.
- Available in low-profile design
- Easy to clean
- Comes with heat control features
- Fully immersible
- Does not come with any warranty
7. Zorirushi EA-DCC10 – Pancake Griddle with a Lid
- Cooking Surface: 19 x 12.5-inches
- Material: Aluminum
Unlike various other products on the market, this one comes with a lid that increases the efficiency and performance of the griddle to a large extent.
It has also got variable heat settings. You can select the temperature settings from 176 to 425 degrees F.
Let us warn you that this product is extremely expensive because of the high-quality titanium coating on aluminum base and overall mechanism of the product.
This one has got larger surface area of 19 x 12.5-inches which means that it can suit your medium to large family. You can prepare a large batch of pancakes in a single go.
Another great thing about this product is that it is fully immersible. The body guard and cooking plate, both can be washed in water.
However, this is not dishwasher safe. The thing is that titanium coating is sensitive and any kind of scratch can appear on it.
- Comes with a lid
- Comes with variable heat settings
- Fully immersible
- Large in size
- Very expensive
- Not dishwasher friendly
8. Cuisinart MCP45-25NS – Pancake Griddle in Tri-Ply Design
- Cooking Surface: 10 x 18-inches
- Material: Stainless Steel
It has tri-ply and hard-anodized design for added durability, and it evenly distributes heat on all the nooks and corners of the griddle. It is also because of the heat surround technology that pancakes are cooked evenly and perfectly.
This one is a fitting option for medium-sized families. It has a cooking surface of 10 x 18-inches which give you suitable space to make multiple pancakes at a time.
The material used here is stainless steel. It is not used in any other model. The best thing about this material is that it is less demanding in maintenance.
The riveted handles stay cool as you cook. It makes handling easy and comfortable. The non-stick interior help you cook pancakes on minimum oil.
The product is dishwasher safe. Although there is one drawback here that the product does not work as effectively on induction. So, you have to make sure that the product is used on the stove.
- Tri-ply design
- Handles remain cool even after heating
- Non-stick coating
- Low maintenance material
- Does not work as effectively on induction
9. Nordic Ware 1930 – Versatile Pancake Griddle
Photo: Nordic Ware
- Material: Aluminium
The next model in the list is from Nordic. It is a versatile model as you can use the pan to make pancakes as well as waffles.
The griddle can accommodate 7 x 3-inches pancakes. So, we won’t recommend this model for large families.
The heavy-duty material of this product is cast-aluminium. It has also got non-stick finish so that the batter doesn’t stick on the surface. This is one of the best stovetop pancake griddles on our list.
The construction is durable, and it is also very easy to handle. The cleaning is also convenient. It is dishwasher-friendly. Overall, this is a decent product.
- Can be used for making pancakes as well as waffles
- Comes with non-stick coating
- Dishwasher friendly
- Not suitable for large families
10. Oster CKSTGRFM18W-TECO – Pancake Griddle with DuraCeramic Non-stick Coating
- Cooking Surface: 10 x 18-inches
- Material: Ceramic
Unlike any of the models recommended above, the unique point about this one is the amazing titanium-infused, duraceramic, non-stick coating that can last 8 times more than conventional non-stick coatings.
However, you can rest assured that the PTFE and PFOA-free ceramic coating will not flake or peel away. It comes with adjustable temperature controls for efficient cooking. This is a durable product.
There is a warming tray that comes with the griddle that keep your food warm until you are ready to consume. Both the trays are removable but not dishwasher safe.
This is an energy efficient product that will not only save your time but also help you safe a lot on energy bills. It makes cooking 30% faster and easier than competitive models.
- Comes with Duraceramic non-stick coating
- 30% faster cooking
- Safe on energy bills
- Durable product
- Not dishwasher safe
How to Buy the Best Pancake Griddle
Ok, so, next in this pancake griddle review is the tips to find the best griddle. Without any further ado, let’s just start looking at the tips.
1. Electric or Manual
In general, there are two main types of pancake griddles.
Mechanism: The mechanism is the same in electric and manual pancake griddle. Heat is supplied from the bottom through stove or electric heating unit to prepare pancakes.
So, as far as mechanism is concerned, there is not much difference between both the griddles other than that one works on electricity and the other works on stovetop.
Cooking Surface: Well, the cooking surface of the electric griddles is more than a conventional stovetop griddle because the stove is not too large to accommodate a large-sized griddle.
So, if you have a large family then best is to pick an electric griddle because this way, you can make a large batch of pancakes in a single go.
Operation Cost: Clearly, anything that operates on electricity will consume more power and thus be costlier than the other option. Electric griddles suck a lot of power as you use them. They have high operating cost.
On the contrary, the gas is rather cheap and eventually, the stovetop griddles have less operation cost.
Only if you have the best electric pancake griddle, that is less in energy consumption, you can buy the model in contrast to the manual one.
Price: So, the electric griddle is pricier than the manual one. Well, there is a lot of engineering in the electric model and these days, you can find various attractive features as well.
All these perks come with a price which is higher than a conventional manual griddle.
Buying Advice: If you are looking for an advice then we will only say that one cannot suggest on which griddle to buy because every household has its own needs. The cost of the griddle varies and so as the overall mechanism. So, make your best pick from the above-mentioned options.
The best pancake griddles are available in a variety of materials. They all differ in durability, thermal conductivity, and uniform heat distribution like features.
Most of the people pick aluminium pancake griddles because they are less in maintenance and evenly distributes the heat for proper cooking. Our recommendation on the best aluminum pancake griddle is the Presto 07047 pancake griddle.
Iron cast is also quite appreciated, but they are heavy. However, it has been assimilated that they are steadier than other materials.
These griddles also have non-stick coating on the top. This way, the batter doesn’t stick to the surface and is easier to remove the pancake. Well, whatever material you select, make sure that it is high quality and durable.
If you wish to find the highest-quality iron cast product then our recommendation is the Lodge 17L9OG3 pancake griddle as it comes with lifetime durability.
The pancake griddles are available in different sizes. Your selection of size depends on the approach of your cooking.
If you are an occasional pancake maker, only when the house is full of guests then you probably need a larger sized griddle. You can select the Black & Decker GD2051B pancake griddle as it is available in extra large size.
In the contrary case, a small one can suffice. It depends on the usability and the number of pancakes that you have to make at one time.
4. Ease to Clean
Well, no one wants a griddle that is too complex to clean. People frequently make pancakes at home and if cleaning the griddle will be a complex task then that will increase the afterwork manifolds.
As far as this feature is concerned, first you have to make sure that you are buying a compatible material which does not react to the water a lot.
Secondly, try and buy a griddle which is dishwasher safe. This way, your work will be limited to half. Before making a purchase, always ensure that the griddle is easy to clean.
So, we believe that now you can easily find the best pancake griddle as per your needs. In nutshell, we have specified some far-fetched models in the niche that we believe are the most amazing models in the market.
Our top recommendation is the Presto 07061 pancake griddle which is high in performance and available on an affordable price.
We leave the rest on you because making a choice between electric or stovetop griddle is completely one’s own choice.
In this post:
- 10 Best Pancake Griddles – Review
- 1. Presto 07061 – Best Overall Pancake Griddle
- 2. Faberware 21745 – Most Affordable Pancake Griddle
- 3. Lodge 17L9OG3 – Most Durable Pancake Griddle
- 4. Anolon 82854 – Pancake Griddle with Lifetime Warranty
- 5. Black & Decker GD2051B – Extra-Large Pancake Griddle
- 6. Presto 07047 – Pancake Griddle in Low Profile Design
- 7. Zorirushi EA-DCC10 – Pancake Griddle with a Lid
- 8. Cuisinart MCP45-25NS – Pancake Griddle in Tri-Ply Design
- 9. Nordic Ware 1930 – Versatile Pancake Griddle
- 10. Oster CKSTGRFM18W-TECO – Pancake Griddle with DuraCeramic Non-stick Coating
- How to Buy the Best Pancake Griddle